Page 1 of 1

Musher sues knife maker

Posted: Sat May 12, 2012 8:03 pm
by Netpackrat
Is knife, is sharp...

*Shakes head*

Dunno, I guess if he can show that the design of the lock mechanism is bad and caused it to fail, then he might have a case.

Re: Musher sues knife maker

Posted: Sat May 12, 2012 9:18 pm
by Weetabix
How did he manage that? You pull with a gut hook.

Re: Musher sues knife maker

Posted: Sat May 12, 2012 9:28 pm
by Netpackrat
All I can figure is that the gut hook was on the back of the blade, and he was pulling with a backhand motion, and managed to somehow release the lock.

Re: Musher sues knife maker

Posted: Sun May 13, 2012 6:58 am
by arctictom
Active natural selection should have retired a large majority of the mushing community, but snowmachines and modern technology have saved more than required, too often.
I am surprised he didn't cut his leg off.

Re: Musher sues knife maker

Posted: Mon May 14, 2012 7:18 am
by Erik
Netpackrat wrote:All I can figure is that the gut hook was on the back of the blade, and he was pulling with a backhand motion, and managed to somehow release the lock.
From the article:
Seavey's lawyer, Bill Ingaldson, said the knife the musher cut himself with suffers a serious design flaw: The lever or button used to release the locking blade is near the middle of the handle and can be depressed when the gut hook is used as intended. That frees the blade to close on the user's fingers, he said.
There was nothing wrong with the knife, they're just claiming that the release button is in the wrong place on that model. To me, that's like arguing that the classic Mora knives has a design flaw because they don't have a finger guard, so your fingers may slide down on the blade. Sure, it may not be the perfect and safest solution for you, but it's pretty obvious that's how it is when you buy it. If you buy a knife like that, then you need to use it properly. You don't stab violently with a Mora Classic #1 and then complain it was the knifes fault you cut yourself.
This guy shouldn't be allowed sharp objects if he doesn't get the concept of making sure his fingers are kept away from the sharp end.